Menopause, HRT & the Over-Medicalisation Trap
The Medicalisation of Menopause - HRT
Lately, it seems impossible to open a news site or turn on the television without encountering an urgent discussion about menopause. In New Zealand, the television documentary Menopause and Us, fronted by our national treasure Robyn Malcolm, has thrown the spotlight firmly onto the physical and emotional distress so many midlife women endure.
Let me be clear right from the outset:
I have no desire to criticise the programme’s makers. For decades, women’s midlife health has been treated as a taboo topic, swept under the carpet, or dismissed as mere hysteria. Bringing this conversation out into the open—validating the genuine suffering of women dealing with debilitating night sweats, clinical depression, panic attacks, muscle, joint and tendon pain—performs a much-needed public service.
However, watching the surrounding discourse, I am deeply troubled by what is being left out, or given token attention.
The implicit message being broadcast to New Zealand women is that menopause is an acute deficiency disease, and that Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) is the miraculous solution that every perimenopausal and menopausal woman ought to take. Very little is said about the documented risks of long-term hormone therapy, the physiological necessity of keeping doses to the absolute minimum effective level, or using it for the shortest possible duration.
Instead, we are witnessing the relentless medicalisation of yet another natural human life-stage process. More money for the Medical Machine, less good health, and less money for the individual.
From Godzone to "DrugsZone": The Polypharmacy Pipeline
Over the years, I have written extensively about how New Zealand has drifted from a vigorous, outdoors-loving population into a medicated society trapped by polypharmacy. In a rushed, guideline-driven, for-profit healthcare system, the pattern is predictable: a physiological imbalance is labelled as a disease, and that disease is immediately met with a lucrative prescription pad.
When a woman enters her late forties and experiences sleep disruption, brain fog, or emotional lability, what happens? All too often, she is first offered an antidepressant or a sleeping tablet, then another for the tummy upset. When hot flushes arrive, HRT is layered on top. If fluid retention, elevated blood pressure, or gallbladder issues follow, further drugs, and even surgery, are prescribed to manage the side effects of the previous ones.
Before long, a healthy woman is taking three, four, or five daily medications. As I often point out, once someone is on multiple pharmaceuticals, no medical professional on earth can accurately predict how those chemicals interact within the biological supercomputer of the human body.
What is funded gets prescribed. What is not funded—functional nutrition, tissue mineral testing, and deep lifestyle restructuring—is quietly ignored, or given passing attention. But the critical question remains: Why has a natural biological transition become an acute medical emergency for an entire generation of women?
Menopause is an Unmasking Event
Menopause is not a disease. It is a programmed, natural threshold. During a woman’s reproductive years, the ovaries produce the vast majority of her sex hormones. As ovarian follicular activity gradually winds down, nature’s design is for the body to transition its secondary hormone production over to the adrenal glands and peripheral tissues.
The adrenal glands are meant to pick up the slack, producing hormone precursors like DHEA and androstenedione, which are converted into the estrogens and progesterone necessary for healthy post-menopausal vitality.
The problem today is not that the ovaries are retiring; it is that the backup system is already burnt out.
Over several decades of analysing thousands of Hair Tissue Mineral Analyses (HTMAs), a glaring pattern has emerged: the severity of menopausal symptoms is directly correlated with indicators of chronic adrenal exhaustion and cellular mineral depletion.
Women in our modern society have transitioned from traditional, agrarian, community-grounded rhythms into the concrete jungle and the relentless corporate rat race. They carry a daily burden of wall-to-wall stress, juggling demanding careers, family logistics, and endless digital connectivity. By the time a modern woman reaches her forties, she has spent twenty years operating in constant sympathetic nervous system dominance ("fight-or-flight"). By my estimation, about 80 % of the women I test have patterns consistent with chronic fatigue, and about 60 % of the men tested have similar patterns.
This chronic stress acts as a massive nutrient sink. The adrenal glands consume vast quantities of vital micronutrients to produce survival hormones like cortisol and adrenaline:
Vitamin C (the adrenal cortex has the highest concentration of vitamin C in the human body)
Bioavailable Magnesium (rapidly dumped via the kidneys during acute and chronic stress)
Zinc and Selenium
The full complex of B vitamins, particularly B5 (pantothenic acid) and B6
Stress pack: two taken in the morning and one around midday, with a further one sometimes later in the day may be all that is required in terms of supplementation. But supplemen remedies are best guided by HTMA, with practitioner support.
When a woman’s adrenals are run into the ground, and her cellular reserves of these essential nutrients are dry, the biological handover fails. Instead of a smooth, gentle recalibration, the body experiences a catastrophic hormonal crash.
Free-Range Living: Reconnecting With Mother Nature
This brings us to a much wider truth about how we live today.
Human beings were never designed for an indoor, fluorescent-lit, sedentary existence lived in the thrall of glowing screens and corporate deadlines. For generations, New Zealanders enjoyed what I like to call a free-range life: children roaming freely outdoors, families eating home-grown produce, and daily rhythms dictated by natural daylight, physical vitality, and genuine community connection.
Our bodies are inseparable from Mother Nature. When we divorce ourselves from her cycles—when we stop walking in the fresh air, when our feet never touch the earth, when our food is ultra-processed and stripped of trace minerals, and when quiet reflection is replaced by relentless adrenaline—our biology begins to unravel. The endocrine system is simply the first to ring the alarm bell.
If we genuinely desire New Zealand to be the best place in the world to live and raise a healthy family, we have to reclaim that free-range spirit. That means designing a lifestyle where our children and grandchildren are grounded in outdoor resilience, where real nourishment comes before convenience, and where women and men alike are supported to live in harmony with natural biological seasons rather than fighting them with synthetic chemicals. True vitality cannot be packaged into a blister pack; it is cultivated through daily kinship with the natural world.
The 20-Year Principle: Investing Ahead of Disease
My universal philosophy of health is straightforward: you must invest to stay 20 years ahead of disease. You do not wait until the day you retire to start putting money into your pension fund; similarly, women in their twenties and thirties must actively invest in their hormonal and glandular reserves.
Building that biological capital requires deliberate, non-negotiable foundations:
Nutrient-Dense Food: A diet composed of real, unadulterated food providing complete proteins, healthy fats, and the full spectrum of essential minerals and fat-soluble vitamins.
Adrenal & Glandular Support: Targeted supplementation with balanced B vitamins, vitamin C, zinc, selenium, and bioavailable magnesium, ideally guided by objective cellular testing rather than guesswork.
Daily Autonomic Rest: We must deliberately declutter our lives from unnecessary stressors. Each day should include structured parasympathetic downtime—whether through meditation, breathwork, or an old-fashioned midday catnap or siesta.
Toxic Burden Reduction: Minimising exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals, synthetic fragrances, pesticides, heavy metals, and excess stimulants that place a heavy detoxification load on the liver. A good starting point for improving the body's ability to cope with toxins is my citrus peel recipe.
Alofa’s Journey: A Transition Without Panic
This is not theoretical. My partner, Alofa, now in her sixties, navigated this transition first-hand.
Her menopausal transition involved roughly a year of disturbed sleep, night sweats, and bodily changes. These symptoms are real and can be uncomfortable. But because we had laid down nutritional and lifestyle groundwork years in advance, she handled the transition without panic.
Guided by hair tissue mineral analysis, we provided targeted nutritional support, focused on adrenal health, prioritised daily rest, and allowed her physiology the time it needed to find its new equilibrium. We did not reach for the medicine bottle.
One day, Alofa turned to me and realised that several months had passed without a single unpleasant symptom. Her transition had simply resolved—naturally, quietly, and completely. While I am writing this, Alofa is riding her bicycle along the wind-swept Wellington coastline. Her post‑menopausal years are now free from monthly menstruation, and being lived to the full, and in excellent drugs-free health.
The Rational, Win-Win Approach
Does this mean hormone replacement therapy has no place? Not at all.
As investigative journalist Alex Berenson noted in his reporting on the Women’s Health Initiative, and as Dr Garnet Anderson (the lead author of the landmark 2002 JAMA paper) acknowledged in Part Two of his investigation, for some women menopause is an absolute, debilitating nightmare. When a woman’s quality of life has completely collapsed under the weight of unrelenting clinical depression, crippling anxiety, or sheer exhaustion, judicious medical support can be a compassionate and necessary temporary bridge.
This is not an anti-HRT stance. It is an argument against the uncritical, blanket medicalisation of a natural life phase.
Addressing root causes—nourishing the cellular terrain, restoring adrenal reserves, and reconnecting with natural rhythms—creates a true win-win outcome:
For the woman who wishes to avoid drugs: Building deep biological reserves allows her body to navigate the menopausal threshold naturally and comfortably, just as nature intended.
For the woman who requires medical therapy: Restoring the underlying biological terrain ensures that HRT works far more effectively, allowing her doctor to prescribe the minimum effective dose for the shortest possible duration, while dramatically lowering the risk of adverse side effects and preventing a descent into lifelong polypharmacy.
Before we surrender another natural phase of human life to lifelong pharmaceutical management, let us look beneath the surface. Support the terrain, rebuild the reserves, and give the body’s innate intelligence the raw materials and natural environment it needs to thrive.
Medical disclaimer: The information on this website is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for personalised medical advice. If you have a medical condition or concerns about your health, consult an appropriately qualified health professional.
Comments