top of page

Playing the Man and Shifting the Goalposts: Why Health Science Scepticism Matters

11 minutes ago
8 min read
Comic rugby scene: boy in red striped jersey tackles black-clad player amid crowd; referee and fans shout, Playing the man, not the ball!

Why "Playing the Man" and "Shifting the Goalposts" Tactics Sit Uncomfortably With a Health Science Sceptic

Anyone who has spent time on a rugby field, or a netball court in New Zealand knows the difference between contesting the ball fairly and resorting to unsporting tactics. When a player abandons the ball to take out an opponent with a late hit or an off-the-ball tackle, every spectator in the stand recognises what is happening. Equally familiar is the frustration of trying to play a fair match when the referee figuratively shifts the goalposts during the game. This might involve interpreting the rules of the game differently for one team and in another way for their opponents, to ensure that the favoured team wins. This may be to conveniently overlook slight knock‑ons or forward passes by one team, while heavily penalising their opposing team for similar errors. The scoreboard loses all meaning.


Over the past 20-30 years, as I gradually awoke to the corruption of medicine, I have watched both of those unsporting habits migrate from the sports field into medicine, public health policy, and statistical reporting. In genuine science, open questioning and health science scepticism are the ball. Every measurement, every hypothesis, and every medical intervention should be tested, challenged, and refined in daylight against fixed, reliable standards. Yet when experienced clinicians, researchers, and ordinary citizens raise uncomfortable questions about pandemic-era data, vaccine safety reporting, or injury compensation, the institutional reflex has too often been to play the man while shifting the statistical goalposts mid-match.


"When institutions abandon open scientific debate to attack the questioner and move the goalposts mid-game, they reveal a lack of confidence in their own data."

What Shifting the Goalposts Means in Health Surveillance

In logic and public debate, shifting the goalposts means unilaterally changing the rules, baselines, or standards of proof in the middle of an inquiry, usually when the original criteria begin producing inconvenient results. In public health statistics and pharmacovigilance, this rarely involves altering individual medical records. Instead, it happens through methodological reclassification that breaks comparability over time. You cannot measure safety or harm accurately if your ruler stretches or shrinks halfway through the measurement.


When a novel medicine or vaccine is rolled out rapidly to millions of healthy people, including children, under emergency or provisional authorisation, honest science demands at least ten full years of consistent monitoring against fixed pre-rollout baselines. A ten-year watch is essential to capture both immediate reactions and slow-developing autoimmune, neurological, or cardiovascular conditions. Yet across five distinct areas of post-vaccination surveillance, the rules of measurement have been altered only a couple of years into the match:


First, active surveillance is wound down early. During the 2021 and 2022 rollout in New Zealand, Medsafe published dedicated, frequent COVID-19 Vaccine Safety Reports tracking serious adverse events and observed-versus-expected mortality rates against pre-pandemic baselines, alongside proactive follow-up tools such as the Post Vaccine Symptom Check. Once Medsafe transitioned to its new pharmacovigilance database in late 2023 and archived those dedicated safety pages in August 2024, COVID-19 vaccines were folded back into routine annual adverse drug reaction summaries. When active prompting stops and reporting reverts to passive systems, reported injury numbers inevitably drop, creating the illusion that biological risk has vanished simply because the searchlight was switched off.   


Second, baselines and observation windows are narrowed or reset. Across the Tasman, the Australian Bureau of Statistics overhauled its excess mortality modelling in July 2026. Having measured pandemic-era deaths against a 2013 to 2019 pre-pandemic baseline using its Serfling model, the agency replaced it with a rolling baseline that incorporates post-2020 mortality years (excluding the 2022 spike). Raising the expected baseline pushed excess mortality figures into negative territory. When Senator Alex Antic pressed officials during Senate Estimates hearings to calculate the 2024 and 2025 numbers under the original model, the agency took the question on notice. When an agency takes a question on notice, it means the officials cannot or will not answer the question on the spot during the hearing, and instead formally promise to look into the details and provide a written answer later. "Later" can mean a lengthy delay. Similarly, restricting safety monitoring to narrow 14-day or 21-day windows post-injection, or updating background disease rates with post-rollout data, absorbs elevated injury rates into the new normal.   


Third, reclassification and the loss of control groups remove the yardstick. Folding a novel product back into general annual drug tables alongside decades-old routine medicines dilutes high report volumes and removes dedicated public safety reviews. At the same time, unblinding clinical trial placebo groups early and ceasing stratified comparisons between vaccinated and unvaccinated cohorts eliminates the long-term control group required to audit cumulative ten-year outcomes. This creates a self-reinforcing loop: agencies wind down active tracking, published safety signals decline, and that decline is then cited as proof that ongoing monitoring is unnecessary.   


Institutional Incentives and the Gatekeeper Problem

Why do public agencies and health authorities gravitate toward methods that normalise post-rollout data and raise the bar for claimants? You do not need an elaborate conspiracy theory to understand human institutions. As I have observed across more than five decades in rehabilitation, sports medicine, and public health, organisations respond to financial, legal, and reputational incentives.


Here in New Zealand, the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) sits squarely at the centre of that tension. Under the Accident Compensation Act, New Zealanders gave up the right to sue for personal injury in exchange for a no-fault system designed to provide timely rehabilitation and fair compensation. Yet when an injured person suffers severe, lifelong harm following a medical procedure or vaccination, the lifetime rehabilitation and earnings-related compensation costs can run into millions of dollars for a single case.


With ACC facing multi-billion-dollar underwriting deficits and a declining funding ratio in its Treatment Injury Account, the institutional pressure to tighten gatekeeping and move the bar of proof for claimants is immense. Thousands of New Zealanders who lodged COVID-19 vaccine injury claims have encountered high decline rates and complex medico-legal hurdles. Because regulators wound down active long-term tracking, injured people with complex, multi-system conditions have less official epidemiological data to cite, making it easier for assessors to dismiss delayed or novel injuries as coincidental. At the same time, former policymakers, health officials, and regulators who promoted absolute assurances that the intervention was "safe and effective", enforced employment mandates, and endorsed incentives ranging from fast food vouchers to cash prizes for schoolchildren have a powerful reputational incentive to avoid an institutional reckoning. Admitting that the harm was greater than advertised would call into question the ethics of coercion and the failure of informed consent.


"In genuine science, there is no such thing as heresy, only hypotheses waiting to be tested against honest evidence."

Medical Heresy and the Chilling Effect on Whistleblowers

Nowhere is the practice of playing the man rather than the ball more damaging than in the treatment of dissenting health professionals and whistleblowers. Science is not an ideology, and medicine is not a church whose doctrines must never be questioned. Yet, during the pandemic response, the official position on vaccine safety and effectiveness was too often treated as beyond reasonable challenge. Within the Medical Council of New Zealand and the wider health bureaucracy, doctors, nurses and other health practitioners who raised legitimate questions about vaccine safety, effectiveness or public health policy risked being labelled as promoters of vaccine hesitancy. Rather than having their concerns examined openly and on their scientific merits, some faced complaints, investigations, disciplinary proceedings and threats to their professional livelihoods. This is a troubling approach to scientific disagreement. Good medicine depends on open inquiry, professional independence and the willingness to question prevailing assumptions, especially when the health and wellbeing of the public are at stake.


That climate of medical heresy created a profound chilling effect. Clinicians became reluctant to report suspected adverse reactions, hesitant to grant medical exemptions, and fearful of discussing individual risk-benefit profiles openly with their patients.


The treatment of former Health New Zealand database administrator Barry Young illustrates what happens when an insider raises alarms about anomalies in the data. Rather than responding to his concerns about mortality clusters across vaccination sites by publishing fully anonymised, auditable datasets for independent biostatisticians to examine and debate openly, the state deployed injunctions, suppression orders, and criminal charges. Whether one agrees or disagrees with Young's statistical interpretation, or with the method by which he disclosed the records, spending millions of dollars to prosecute and silence the messenger rather than opening the data to transparent scientific scrutiny sends an unmistakable warning to anyone else inside the system who might consider speaking up.


"You do not protect public trust by silencing the whistleblower; you protect it by putting the raw data on the table for everyone to inspect."

Restoring Curiosity and Ten-Year Scientific Integrity

True scientific authority does not need censorship, shifted baselines, or disciplinary threats to defend itself. As the editors of major medical journals have reminded the profession over the years, science is an iterative process, never a settled decree. Nothing in medicine is beyond scrutiny, and any new pharmaceutical rolled out under emergency provisions warrants at least a full decade of transparent, consistent tracking against fixed pre-rollout baselines.


If New Zealand wants to rebuild public trust in its health institutions, regulators, and statistical agencies, we need to return to basic sportsmanship. Leave the man alone, nail the goalposts firmly into the turf for a full ten-year match, publish the unvarnished data in full, and let open, respectful health science scepticism determine where the truth lies.



Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional health advice.


References:


Primary focus keyword: health science scepticism

Title tag: Health Science Scepticism: Playing the Man & Goalposts

Meta description: Explore why health science scepticism and ten-year safety monitoring matter when agencies shift baselines, censor doctors, and silence whistleblowers.

URL slug: health-science-scepticism-playing-the-man-shifting-goalposts

Post excerpt: Using the sporting rules of playing the ball and keeping the goalposts fixed, Gary Moller explains what shifting the goalposts means in vaccine safety monitoring, examining Medsafe reporting changes, ABS baselines, ACC gatekeeping, and the silencing of whistleblowers.

Featured image alt text: Rugby goalposts and ball on a New Zealand sports field representing health science scepticism and fixed standards

25-word summary: Gary Moller explains what shifting the goalposts means for post-vaccination monitoring, examining Medsafe reporting, ABS baselines, ACC gatekeeping, and why health science scepticism matters.

Blog tags: Health Politics, Vaccines, Adverse Events, Medical Freedom, ACC SEO


keywords: health science scepticism, shifting the goalposts, Medsafe reporting, excess mortality baseline, ACC treatment injury, Barry Young whistleblower, ten-year vaccine monitoring


Suggested related posts: When Medicine Loses Its Curiosity & Independence (https://www.garymoller.com/post/when-medicine-loses-its-curiosity-independence), Has ACC Become the Very System Sir Owen Woodhouse Tried to Replace? (https://www.garymoller.com/post/has-acc-become-the-very-system-sir-owen-woodhouse-tried-to-replace), Barry "The Whistle": Hero - New Zealander of the Decade (https://www.garymoller.com/post/barry-young-whistleblower-hero-or-felon)

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page