top of page

Breaking Out of the Cage: Why Westminster Democracy Beats Co-Governance and Tribalism

32 minutes ago
4 min read
Rooster and three hens pecking in leafy ground cover, with bright red combs and brown, black, and white feathers.
Healthy, resilient Freerange Chooks

Co-Governance and Tribalism

Constitutional governance is a sensitive topic in New Zealand, and it is one I would ordinarily leave to the political commentators. Yet with relentless debate around Westminster democracy, Treaty interpretation, and institutional co-governance, every citizen has a stake in how our country is run.


When I was a teenager living in Putaruru, I kept a menagerie of caged birds (finches, canaries, budgies, love birds, quail and more) alongside a small free-range flock of pigeons, chickens and bantams. Looking after them taught me a lesson I have never forgotten. A bird locked inside a wire cage is fed processed rations, shielded from the weather, and sorted according to its breed. My caged birds did fine, but industrial cage-farming is another matter. Following hatching, their lustre is pale and listless, their feathers are mangy, and the bird never learns how to scratch for itself. Open the gate onto fresh pasture, and the contrast is immediate. If they survive transitioning the first few days from cage to freedom, the now liberated birds develop vibrant plumage, strong legs, and sharp instincts because they were free to roam, forage, and live as nature intended.


Modern New Zealand faces a similar choice, not only in how we look after our health, but in how we govern ourselves. Whether we are talking about medicine or politics, the same caged logic is being sold to us as progress. In health, bureaucracy, pharmaceutical companies, and processed food manufacturers wrap people in cotton wool, encouraging us to outsource our bodies to self-appointed experts rather than trusting our own resilience and common sense. In politics, proposals like He Puapua and race-based co-governance apply that exact same cage-building mindset to Westminster democracy.


"Whether we are talking about your health or your citizenship, the modern system runs on the exact same caged logic."

Escaping the Old Cages of History

To see why revived tribalism sits so uneasily with the New Zealand character, it helps to remember why our ancestors came here in the first place. My own family carries both Polynesian and European roots, and both sides of the family tree tell the same story of breaking free from hereditary control.


On my Pacific side, through Samoan and Cook Islands heritage, rigid tribalism is not an abstract theory from a university textbook. Only a few generations ago, small ruling families on island chiefdoms held absolute power over land, food, and life itself, while ordinary people laboured beneath them and bore the brunt whenever shortages struck. On my European side, ancestors from Scotland, Denmark, and Poland sailed across the world in the late nineteenth century to escape feudal landlords, rigid class systems, and aristocratic privilege.


They did not cross oceans to recreate hereditary rule under a new name. They came to New Zealand for a clean slate where people with practical skills, a strong work ethic, and sound morals could stand on their own feet and build a decent life for their children.


Westminster Democracy Versus Corporate Tribalism

Even after a record number of Maori members of Parliament were elected on merit across the political spectrum in the 2026 election, a vocal political and academic class continues to push for constitutional transformation, parallel courts, and unelected boards appointed by ancestry. Some commentators even suggest that elected Maori representatives do not truly count unless they conform to an approved ideological agenda, while legal academics campaign to elevate the Treaty above Parliament so that unelected judges and tribunals can override laws passed by voters. Under Westminster democracy, sovereignty rests with Parliament, and every Member of Parliament is accountable to the people at the ballot box. Replacing that principle with permanent appointments based on lineage strips ordinary citizens of their democratic voice.


"We do not need to perpetuate tribalism for Maori to benefit, any more than we need feudal landlords for Europeans to thrive."

Advocates dress this up as partnership and fairness. In reality, it is a return to sorting human beings into separate pens based on bloodline. Since the late nineteenth century, ordinary Maori families have too often been dominated by a small elite class, and modern Treaty settlements have frequently reinforced that divide. While multi-million-dollar tribal corporations accumulate vast commercial assets, everyday working families in our towns and cities rarely see that wealth trickle down to their kitchen tables. Handing permanent political vetoes and public funding to unaccountable corporate boards does not empower ordinary Maori, Pasifika, or European New Zealanders. It simply creates a modern aristocracy that cannot be voted out.


Choosing Free-Range Citizenship

True human flourishing requires personal sovereignty. Just as a healthy body needs real food, sunshine, movement, and meaningful challenge rather than a lifetime of dependency on pills, a healthy society needs free, self-reliant citizens standing as equals before one law.


"Westminster democracy works because every citizen holds one vote of equal value, regardless of ancestry."

Most urban Maori, Pasifika, and everyday New Zealanders of every background have zero desire to live inside an ancestral cage managed by bureaucrats and tribal executives. We thrive when we are free to associate voluntarily, build our own communities, raise strong and resilient children, and judge one another by character and contribution rather than lineage. New Zealand was built to be a beacon of freedom and common sense. It is time to leave the cages behind, defend Westminster democracy, and embrace free-range citizenship.


Reading


  1. Strategic Voting Election 2026: Would You Trust These Politicians With the Keys to Your Business? (https://www.garymoller.com/post/nz-election-2026-strategic-voting-litmus-test)


  2. New Zealand Government Debt and the Future We Are Leaving Our Children (https://www.garymoller.com/post/new-zealand-government-debt-future-generations)


  3. If I Grow Vegetables and Store Gas Bottles, Am I a Potential Tom Phillips? (https://www.garymoller.com/post/tom-phillips-warning-signs-preparedness-extremism)

  4. Is tribalism the greatest threat to our liberal democracy? https://www.garymoller.com/post/is-tribalism-the-greatest-threat-to-our-liberal-democracy

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page